Home / Aerospace and defense program execution
Your casting supplier just quoted a lead time that breaks your schedule, or your foundry is the single point of failure on the critical path. Metal additive manufacturing can remove that dependency, but only if the part is qualified properly. Set Boundaries manages additive manufacturing as a program: part selection, qualification, supplier readiness and the move into production.
Why are aerospace programs turning to additive manufacturing?
Three reasons dominate. Lead time: castings and forgings can take many months, especially where tooling is needed or foundry capacity is scarce, while additive parts need no hard tooling. Supply chain resilience: a qualified additive alternative gives a program a second route when a single foundry is constrained. And design freedom: additive processes can produce geometries that are difficult or impossible to cast or machine, consolidating assemblies and reducing weight. Of the three, lead time is often the one that makes the business case on programs under schedule pressure.
Which parts are good candidates?
| Factor | Favors additive | Favors traditional methods |
|---|---|---|
| Volume | Low to moderate quantities | High, stable volumes |
| Lead time pressure | Long casting or tooling lead times on the critical path | Short, reliable supply |
| Geometry | Complex internal features, consolidated assemblies | Simple shapes that machine or cast easily |
| Size | Fits within available build volumes | Very large parts |
| Criticality | Non-critical or well-understood loading, easier qualification | Highly critical parts with limited schedule for qualification |
| Material | Alloys with established additive processes and data | Alloys without mature additive processing |
What does qualification involve?
Qualification builds confidence at three levels. Material: the powder or wire feedstock and the resulting material properties, including their variability. Process: the specific machine, parameters, build orientation, post-processing such as heat treatment and machining, and the controls that keep them consistent. Part: evidence that this part, built this way, meets its requirements, typically through inspection, testing and first article inspection. The depth of evidence scales with the part's criticality, and the customer usually defines what it will accept.
How is an additive program run?
- Select and screen candidate parts against the factors above, with engineering and the customer.
- Define the qualification requirements with the customer, including standards and acceptance criteria.
- Choose and assess the additive supplier, including machine capability, process control and quality system.
- Design for the process, adapting the part to additive manufacturing where the change is allowed.
- Build, test and inspect qualification articles, including any destructive testing required.
- Complete first article and approvals, including configuration and drawing changes.
- Transition to production with a controlled, capable process and monitoring in place.
Each step belongs in the program's integrated master schedule with realistic durations, because qualification is where additive programs most often lose their schedule advantage.
Which additive processes are used for aerospace metal parts?
| Process | How it works | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| Laser powder bed fusion | A laser melts thin layers of metal powder | Detailed parts with fine features and good surface finish; the most widely used metal process |
| Electron beam powder bed fusion | An electron beam melts powder in a vacuum | Certain titanium and high-temperature alloy parts |
| Directed energy deposition | A laser, electron beam or arc melts wire or powder as it is deposited | Larger parts, near-net shapes and repair of existing components |
| Binder jetting | A binder joins powder, followed by sintering | Higher-volume parts where its material properties are acceptable |
The process choice affects achievable geometry, surface finish, material properties, qualification evidence and cost, so it is made with the part's requirements and the customer's acceptance in view.
How is quality controlled in additive production?
Through control of every input and step, because the material is created as the part is built. That includes managing powder or wire feedstock and its reuse, locking machine and process parameters, building witness specimens alongside parts for testing, monitoring builds where the equipment allows, controlling post-processing, and inspecting parts with methods suited to internal features, often including computed tomography. A frozen, documented process is what lets a qualified part be reproduced consistently in production.
What has to be frozen before the first qualification build?
Anything that can change the material, because evidence gathered on one process does not automatically carry over to another. The material is made as the part is built, so a change to the machine, the parameters or the heat treatment can put earlier test results in question. Settle these items with engineering, quality and the customer before hardware is committed. Each one left open is a chance that a finished test has to be run again.
| Decision | Why it cannot wait | Who needs to agree |
|---|---|---|
| Machine and site | Results from one machine may not transfer to another, even of the same model, unless equivalence has been shown | Engineering, supplier, customer |
| Feedstock specification and reuse rules | Chemistry, particle size and reuse history of the powder all affect the finished material | Materials engineering, supplier quality |
| Process parameters and build orientation | Properties can differ with build direction, so orientation is part of the process being qualified | Materials and design engineering |
| Post-processing route | Stress relief, heat treatment, hot isostatic pressing, machining and surface finishing all change the result and add lead time | Materials engineering, manufacturing |
| Inspection method | The method has to be able to find the flaws that matter in this geometry, including internal features | Quality, customer |
| Test plan and acceptance values | The number of builds and specimens, and what counts as a pass, should be agreed before any results exist | Customer, and the airworthiness organization where relevant |
| Production intent | Evidence from a machine or supplier that production will not use may have to be generated again later | Program lead, supply chain |
Write the frozen items down and put them under change control. A later change may still be the right call, but it should be a decision made with its cost and schedule consequences in view, not something discovered when a test result looks different.
How do you assess an additive supplier?
Ask for evidence of control rather than a sample part. A good-looking sample shows that a supplier printed something well once. A program needs to know the result can be repeated on your schedule, inside your quality system and under your contract terms. The standards named below help structure the questions. None of them makes a part acceptable on its own, and the customer still decides.
| Question | Evidence to ask for |
|---|---|
| Is the quality system right for aerospace work? | AS9100 certification, and whether additive work falls inside its scope |
| Is the machine under control? | Acceptance, calibration and maintenance records. ISO/ASTM 52941 is a published reference for laser powder bed machines in aerospace use. |
| Are the operators qualified? | Training and qualification records. ISO/ASTM 52942 covers operators of these machines for aerospace work. |
| Is feedstock traceable? | Lot records from powder to finished part, reuse limits, and storage and handling controls |
| Who does the post-processing? | Which steps are in house and which are subcontracted, and whether heat treatment and nondestructive testing hold Nadcap accreditation where the customer requires it |
| Is there real capacity? | Machine time committed to your builds, the current queue, and the backup plan if a machine goes down |
| Can it handle controlled data? | How build files and drawings are stored and shared, and whether it can meet DFARS 252.204-7012 and export control requirements where they apply |
| Where does the material come from? | The origin of powder or wire. DFARS 252.225-7009 restricts specialty metals, including titanium and certain nickel alloys, on many defense purchases, so ask your contracts team early how it applies. |
Run this assessment before the order is placed, when you still have a choice. It fits naturally into the supplier planning described in AS9145 APQP and PPAP. A supplier that cannot answer these questions now will be harder to get answers from once the program is late.
What should the business case include?
Schedule, cost and risk, side by side with the traditional route: the lead time avoided, the cost of qualification and any design changes, the unit cost at the expected volume, the reduction in supply chain risk from a second route, and the risk that qualification takes longer than planned. On programs where a casting is on the critical path, the schedule benefit usually dominates, and it should be valued in the program's own terms: the milestone it protects.
Can additive manufacturing repair parts as well as make them?
Yes. Directed energy deposition in particular can add material to worn or damaged components, which are then machined back to shape. For high-value parts with long replacement lead times, a qualified repair can return hardware to service far faster than waiting for a new part. As with new parts, the repair process needs qualification and customer approval, and the repaired part must be inspected to the same requirements as the original. On sustainment programs, repair is often where additive delivers value first, because the business case is immediate and easy to measure.
What experience does Set Boundaries bring?
Holly identified castings as the constraint on a mission-critical airframe-mounted component program, proposed additive manufacturing as the answer, and secured funding and resources to build the capability. That means practical experience of the program side of additive: making the business case, building a qualification approach with customers and airworthiness organizations, and turning month-long casting waits into design changes measured in weeks, rather than only knowledge of the technology.
What does a printed part change in the schedule?
It swaps one long wait for several shorter, less familiar activities, and each of them needs its own line in the schedule. A casting lead time is easy to see because it is one long bar. The printed route looks faster on a slide, but its time is spread across people and vendors who may never have appeared on your schedule before.
| Activity | What sets the duration | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Agreeing the qualification approach | Customer and airworthiness organization availability, and the number of review rounds | Customer actions need owners and dates like any other task |
| Process development | The number of parameter and orientation trials | Set a decision date, or this work has no natural end |
| Qualification builds | Machine queue, build time and the number of builds required | Book machine time early, because additive suppliers have queues too |
| Post-processing | Heat treatment, pressing and machining queues, often at different vendors | Often left out of the print quote, so ask for it separately |
| Testing | Test lab availability and the run time of the tests, especially fatigue | Reserve lab time before the specimens exist |
| Data review and approval | Report writing and customer review cycles | Approval is work with a duration, not an event on a date |
| First article and configuration changes | Drawing, specification and process approvals | Start these early enough to run alongside testing |
Where the program can afford it, keep the cast route open until the printed route is approved. If qualification slips, you still have a path to the milestone, and leadership has a real choice to make. Once these activities sit in the integrated master schedule, you can see whether qualification has become the new critical path. On a program that adopted additive to escape a casting wait, it often has, and it should get the same attention the casting did.
What changes in the configuration and data package?
More than the drawing. A printed part is defined by its drawing and by the process that makes it, so more items need to be identified and controlled than on a cast or machined part. EIA-649 gives the configuration management principles. The list below is where additive tends to catch teams out.
- Drawings and specifications. Casting callouts, material specifications and surface requirements have to be replaced with additive material and process requirements, and the design authority has to approve them.
- The build file. The build layout, support structures and parameter set behave like configuration items. A revision to them can change the part even when the drawing stays the same.
- Build records. Each build needs a record of the machine, feedstock lot, operator and any interruption, traceable to the serial numbers it produced.
- First article. AS9102 calls for a full or partial first article inspection when the manufacturing process, source or location changes. Moving from casting to additive is such a change, and so may be a later move to another machine or supplier.
- Customer approvals. Many contracts and quality clauses require approval before a process or source changes. Check this before qualification spending starts.
- Controlled data. A build file for a defense part can carry the same technical data as its drawing. Treat it that way when sending it to a supplier, under the ITAR or EAR and DFARS 252.204-7012 where they apply.
What goes wrong most often?
Qualification underestimated. The part is printed quickly and then waits months for evidence nobody planned. The wrong part chosen. A highly critical part is picked first, making qualification slow and expensive, when a less critical part would have proven the approach. Post-processing ignored. Heat treatment, machining and surface finishing are part of the process and part of the lead time. Configuration not updated. Drawings, specifications and approvals must change to allow the new process. Supplier capacity assumed. Additive suppliers have queues too.
The main lesson is that qualification strategy decides whether a printed part ever flies. On that program, the approach agreed with the aerospace customers and airworthiness organizations involved was to gather qualification data on the traditionally cast part, then generate equivalent data on additive-manufactured hardware for an apples-to-apples comparison, against frozen material processes and comparable material-property data. A program considering it for the first time should start with the constraint it is solving, such as long casting lead times, and agree the qualification path with the customer before committing hardware.
How did the additive work start?
With a schedule problem, not a technology. On a mission-critical airframe-mounted component program at a Tier 1 supplier, Holly identified castings as a major schedule and supply-chain constraint. Every design change that needed a new casting started a clock the program did not control: tooling had to be made, foundry lead times ran to at least 18 weeks, and defects and rejections could restart the wait. On development hardware, where design changes are expected, each iteration was measured in months.
She proposed additive manufacturing as the way out and put the case to company leadership in program terms: the schedule the castings were costing, the supply-chain exposure of depending on them, and what a qualified alternative would change. Leadership provided funding and resources to develop the capability.
How was qualification approached?
The printing was never the hard part; acceptance was. Rather than argue for printed hardware on its own merits, the approach agreed with foreign aerospace customers and airworthiness organizations was comparative. First obtain qualification data on the traditionally cast part, then generate equivalent data on the additive-manufactured hardware, so the customer and the airworthiness organization could compare like with like. The technical team developed frozen material processes and comparable material-property data, because a comparison only means something when the process that produced the parts is fixed and documented.
Framing qualification this way does two things for a program. It gives the customer a decision it can make on evidence it already trusts, and it turns an open-ended research question into a defined set of builds and tests that can be scheduled, resourced and tracked like any other work on the critical path.
What did it change, and what does it mean for your program?
Design changes could be made in weeks rather than waiting months for new castings, and the business gained a U.S.-based manufacturing solution to a supply-chain constraint.
For a client considering the same move, we apply the method we use on any program. The constraint is established first, in days and dollars against the milestones it threatens. The qualification approach is agreed with the customer, and where relevant the airworthiness organization, before hardware is committed, and recorded in the Project Charter as part of what done means. Qualification builds, tests and approvals go into the integrated Microsoft Project schedule with owners and realistic durations, and are reviewed with the program's other risks and opportunities every month. Customers see progress at least weekly. If additive later becomes a production route, the move is planned as deliberately as any other manufacturing transition.
How do you compare a printed part with a cast one?
Property by property, with matching test methods, and with the part's requirements as the reference. A printed part does not have to match a casting in every respect. It has to meet what the part needs, and every difference has to be understood. The customer sets which comparisons count. These are the ones that usually need the most thought.
| Comparison | Why it is not straightforward | Question to settle early |
|---|---|---|
| Static strength | Printed material can compare well, but values can vary with build direction and position | Which directions and build locations will be tested? |
| Fatigue | Rough as-built surfaces and internal flaws can shorten fatigue life even when static strength looks good | Does the test surface match the surface that will fly? |
| Defects | Castings and printed parts tend to have different flaws, such as shrinkage in one and lack of fusion in the other | Can the casting acceptance criteria be used, or are new ones needed? |
| Dimensions and surfaces | Parts can distort during the build, and support removal leaves witness marks | Which features will be machined, and which stay as built? |
| Service environment | Heat, corrosion, fluids and coatings may affect a printed surface differently | Which service conditions need to be tested again? |
| Variability | A long-running casting may have years of data, while a new additive process has few builds behind it | How many builds, lots and machines are enough to state a value? |
That last row often sets the size of the test program. ASTM F3122 is a published guide to evaluating mechanical properties of additive metals, and the MMPDS handbook is the familiar reference for statistically based design values in metals. If the design needs a statistically based allowable, the specimen count grows quickly, along with the cost and the time. Find that out while the plan is still on paper.
What should a leader ask before approving an additive project?
Ask whether it solves a program problem, then ask who will accept the result. Enthusiasm for the technology is easy to find, and it can fund a lot of printing without moving a milestone. Seven questions usually show whether the proposal is ready.
- What constraint does it remove? The answer should be stated in days and dollars against a named milestone. If the real goal is to build a general capability, evaluate it as a capability investment rather than a program fix.
- Who has to accept it? Name the customer and airworthiness contacts, and say whether they have agreed the approach in principle. On defense work, DoD Instruction 5000.93 sets department policy on additive manufacturing, and the program office still decides for its own part.
- Which part goes first? A less critical part can prove the approach at lower cost and risk.
- What does the full route cost? The estimate should include testing, post-processing, inspection, approvals and the engineering time behind them, not only the print price.
- What is the fallback? Know what happens to the milestone if qualification runs late.
- Who owns it? One person should own the plan, the budget and the customer conversation.
- What would make us stop? Agree the decision points now, while nobody has an investment to defend.
The test is the same one we apply to any spending on a program: treat every dollar as though it were your own. If the team cannot answer these questions, or leadership wants an outside view first, an independent program assessment is a low-cost way to get one.
How does Set Boundaries help?
Set Boundaries runs additive manufacturing work as a program: screening candidate parts, defining qualification with the customer, selecting and managing additive suppliers, scheduling qualification realistically and carrying parts through first article and into production. It is also a recovery tool when a casting is the constraint on a late program, as described in supplier recovery.
If a long-lead casting is holding your program hostage, schedule a call.
Related guides
- Supplier recovery on aerospace programs
- Transitioning a program to production
- First article inspection under AS9102
- AS9145 APQP and PPAP
References
- ISO/ASTM 52900, Additive manufacturing: General principles, fundamentals and vocabulary.
- SAE International, AMS7000 series specifications for additive manufacturing materials and processes.
- NASA, NASA-STD-6030, Additive Manufacturing Requirements for Spaceflight Systems.
- SAE International, AS9102, Aerospace First Article Inspection Requirement.
- ISO/ASTM 52901, Additive manufacturing: General principles, requirements for purchased AM parts.
- ISO/ASTM 52920, Additive manufacturing: Qualification principles, requirements for industrial additive manufacturing processes and production sites.
- ISO/ASTM 52941, Additive manufacturing: Acceptance tests for laser beam powder bed fusion machines for metallic materials for aerospace application.
- ISO/ASTM 52942, Additive manufacturing: Qualifying machine operators of laser metal powder bed fusion machines and equipment used in aerospace applications.
- ASTM F3122, Standard Guide for Evaluating Mechanical Properties of Metal Materials Made via Additive Manufacturing Processes.
- ASTM E3166, Standard Guide for Nondestructive Examination of Metal Additively Manufactured Aerospace Parts After Build.
- US Department of Defense, DoD Instruction 5000.93, Use of Additive Manufacturing in the Department of Defense.
- Metallic Materials Properties Development and Standardization (MMPDS) handbook.
- SAE International, EIA-649, Configuration Management Standard.
- DFARS 252.204-7012, Safeguarding Covered Defense Information and Cyber Incident Reporting.
- DFARS 252.225-7009, Restriction on Acquisition of Certain Articles Containing Specialty Metals.
Questions
Common questions
Can additive manufacturing replace castings on aerospace parts?
Sometimes. Metal additive manufacturing can produce parts that were traditionally cast, often without the long tooling and foundry lead times. Whether it is right depends on the part's material, size, loads, surface and inspection requirements, and on whether the customer will accept the change. Where it fits, it can remove a long-lead dependency from a program's critical path.
How long does it take to qualify an additively manufactured part?
It depends on the part's criticality and the customer's requirements. Qualification typically covers the material, the machine and process parameters, and the part itself, including testing and first article inspection, and it may need customer approval. Non-critical parts can move relatively quickly; flight-critical parts require substantially more evidence. Planning qualification as a project, with its own schedule, is essential.
What standards apply to metal additive manufacturing in aerospace?
This is the question that catches programs out, because the honest answer is that there is no standard you can comply with to make an additive flight part acceptable. There is published material on terminology and process families, and there are company specifications, but nothing that a customer will accept as proof on its own. Acceptance is negotiated with the customer and the airworthiness authority, case by case, against the specific part and the specific process. Anyone who tells you there is a standard to certify to has not taken a flight-critical additive part through qualification. Plan it as a negotiation with an evidence package behind it, not as a compliance exercise.
Is additive manufacturing cheaper than casting?
Usually not, and anyone evaluating it on part price is asking the wrong question. For high-volume simple parts, casting wins on unit cost and will keep winning. Additive uses less material and produces less waste, which is worth having and which everyone in the industry already knows. The reason it gets funded is schedule: removing a long foundry lead time from the critical path is frequently worth more than the entire part-price difference, and that is the number the business case should be built on.
What is the biggest risk in an additive manufacturing program?
Underestimating qualification. Printing a good-looking part is the easy step. Proving that the material properties, process control, inspection and part performance meet aerospace requirements, consistently and on the production machine, takes planning, testing and time. Programs that treat qualification as an afterthought find their schedule advantage disappears.
Has Holly Dekle worked on additive manufacturing programs?
Yes. Holly led the effort to replace long-lead castings on a mission-critical airframe-mounted component with additive-manufactured hardware, including the qualification approach agreed with the aerospace customers and airworthiness organizations involved. That experience of moving a part from a cast baseline to an additive one, through the practical realities of qualification and production, is what Set Boundaries brings to additive programs.
Have a question that is not here? Ask Holly on a short call
